Discussion Forum

Course Assignments - Other tools Clarrification

Course Assignments - Other tools Clarrification

av Kyle Aidan Tenn -
Antal svar: 5

Hey 

I understand AI is not allowed. But for example, other than using the book, if a question asks us to divide numbers by 3 lets say 100 times, or other type of questions for the homework. 

Are these allowed:

  1. A calculator?
  2. Excel?
  3. Google.com (this is extremely tricky now...)
  4. wikipedia
  5. stackoverflow
  6. running the code in python or such
  7. etc?

Or is it simply only AI is not allowed, but all other tools and methods are okay?

In kind,

kyle

Som svar till Kyle Aidan Tenn

Re: Course Assignments - Other tools Clarrification

av Marc Hellmuth -
For these exercises, you are strongly encouraged to work primarily with the course book, lecture notes, and your own reasoning. The main goal is not only to arrive at a correct answer, but to practice the thinking that leads to it. Struggling with a problem, organizing your thoughts, making mistakes, and correcting them are all important parts of learning. When you work through the exercises yourself, you develop a deeper understanding of the material, a better sense of what you have and have not yet understood, and a stronger ability to explain and apply ideas independently. This is much more valuable in the long run than obtaining a quick answer with external help. To achieve these goals, you don't need more than the course book, lecture notes, and your own reasoning!

What is not in the spirit of the assignment is using tools that do the thinking or writing for you — for example, generating solutions, explanations, summaries, or polished text that you then submit as your own work. That is the concern with AI-based tools and similar systems. So the basic principle is: you can use tools that assist with mechanical work, but that do not replace your understanding, reasoning, or writing.

When in doubt, ask yourself: is this tool just helping me compute something, or is it doing the intellectual work I am supposed to do myself?

Anyways, if you use AI tools you must highlight it!
Som svar till Marc Hellmuth

Re: Course Assignments - Other tools Clarrification

av Kyle Aidan Tenn -
I see, just to clarify then. If you do not highlight AI tools there will be disciplinary consequences, but if you use other tools and do not highlight it there will not be disciplinary consequences?

It is just unclear since the phrase: If you use AI tools but do not clearly highlight this in the exercises, the case will be forwarded to the disciplinary board.

So all tools are "allowed" but only AI requires some kind of "highlighting" ?
Som svar till Kyle Aidan Tenn

Sv: Re: Course Assignments - Other tools Clarrification

av Marc Hellmuth -
Yes - you have more or less solved the puzzle yourself: I do not need a formal confession about calculators or Excel, but if a tool is doing the actual thinking or writing for you - especially AI - then that does need to be stated.
Som svar till Marc Hellmuth

Re: Sv: Re: Course Assignments - Other tools Clarrification

av Kyle Aidan Tenn -

Right, since it says on the home page which I need clarification on since it seems contradictory. It states:

>>For the exercises, don't  use of AI tools. [sic]

Thus, wanted to clarify we are allowed to use any tool and even AI tools, it is only if we use AI we need to highlight.

Since on the homepage it says DO NOT use AI tools...? Would it be possible to update the homepage?

Som svar till Kyle Aidan Tenn

Sv: Re: Sv: Re: Course Assignments - Other tools Clarrification

av Marc Hellmuth -
The homepage states it correctly. "For the exercises, don't use AI tools".
Its a recommendation: use pen, paper, book, lecturescript and your brain - you don't need more
(of course, afterwards, a smartphone to make photos and upload a pdf) !

Use of AI-tools without highlighting will be treated as cheating.

See also here:
https://www.su.se/english/divisions/department-of-child-and-youth-studies/education/during-your-studies/plagiarism-cheating-and-self-plagiarism
where its stated that:
"An example of plagiarism is to copy a text verbatim or almost verbatim (this also includes parts of a text or single sentences) without indicating the source. " [eg from ChatGPT and co]

More info also here:
https://www.su.se/enheter/matematiska-institutionen/utbildning/under-utbildningen/hederskodex-och-disciplinarenden-vid-matematiska-institutionen